When it comes to residential roofing, replacing a damaged or deteriorated roof is a major investment. Homeowners and roofing companies alike aim to ensure the project runs smoothly, sticking to the agreed-upon budget and schedule. However, unforeseen issues can arise during the repair process, particularly when it comes to rotten plywood decking hidden beneath the old roof. This raises a fundamental question: can roofers charge extra for replacing rotten plywood, and is it fair to do so?
The Fine Print in Residential Roofing Contracts
Many residential roofing contracts contain a clause that addresses the potential need for replacing damaged plywood decking. This clause usually specifies the cost per square foot or per sheet of plywood, which gives both parties a clear understanding of what to expect if such replacement is necessary. While these clauses vary among contracts, they are essential in preventing disputes and misunderstandings between homeowners and roofing companies.
Why Rotten Plywood Replacement Can Be Necessary
Rotten or deteriorated plywood decking is a common issue in older roofs. It’s usually hidden beneath layers of shingles and underlayment and can go unnoticed until the old roof is removed. Roofers cannot accurately assess the condition of the plywood decking until they reach this crucial stage of the project. The primary reasons for rotten plywood include:
- Moisture Infiltration: Leaks in the old roof can lead to water seeping through and causing rot in the plywood over time.
- Poor Ventilation: Inadequate ventilation in the attic can trap moisture, contributing to plywood deterioration.
- Age: Over the years, plywood can naturally degrade, especially if it was of lower quality or not properly maintained.
The Fairness of Extra Charges for Rotten Plywood Replacement
Both homeowners and roofing companies have valid concerns in this matter. For homeowners, the potential for extra charges can be worrisome, as it may seem like a hidden cost that wasn’t initially disclosed. For roofing companies, replacing rotten plywood is a necessary part of ensuring the structural integrity and longevity of the new roof.
The fairness of charging extra for rotten plywood replacement largely depends on the transparency and communication between both parties. Here are some key factors to consider:
- Transparency in Contracts: Homeowners should carefully review the roofing contract, paying close attention to any clauses related to additional charges for plywood replacement. Likewise, roofing companies must be upfront about these potential costs during the contract negotiation process.
- Inspection and Documentation: Roofers should conduct a thorough inspection before starting the project to identify any pre-existing issues with the plywood decking. Documentation, such as photos and notes, can serve as evidence in case a dispute arises.
- Communication: Open and regular communication between homeowners and roofing companies is essential. Roofers should notify homeowners as soon as they discover rotten plywood, and homeowners should be prepared for the possibility of extra charges.
- Reasonable Pricing: The cost per square foot or per sheet of plywood should be reasonable and competitive within the local market. Homeowners can seek multiple quotes to ensure they are not overcharged.
- Insurance Coverage: Homeowners should also check if their homeowner’s insurance policy covers the replacement of rotten plywood. This may help offset the cost.
In conclusion, the issue of whether roofers can charge extra for replacing rotten plywood decking discovered during a roofing project can be a complex matter. The key is to ensure transparency, communication, and fairness from both parties. Residential roofing contracts that include clear clauses about plywood replacement costs help in preventing disputes and allow for a smoother project overall. Ultimately, both homeowners and roofing companies share the goal of a structurally sound and long-lasting roof, and addressing plywood issues is a necessary step toward achieving that goal.
DISCLAIMER: The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only.
READY LEGAL 